Chad plays a Native American character who falls in love with a white girl. Being white himself, he wears a conspicuous wig and native garb as he runs through Cain's End, trying to escape the wrath of Claire's father, Sheriff Stone. He begs the preacher to intervene on his behalf, but ends up cornered at the business end of the Sheriff's pistol. Claire herself throws herself in front of Chad, defending him. However, at the height of the standoff, the Sheriff conspicuously turns his gun aside and reaches out to clasp arms with Chad, assenting to the marriage.
Later, out of character, Chad asks Walks Upon Earth for advice on how to make his act more authentic, wondering if Walks Upon Earth knows any fighting styles. He sarcastically says he knows "Ti-Cree", which Chad obliviously takes to be a real thing and begins play-fighting with him. However, Chad gets too rough and knocks him over along with Claire, also out of character, and they both collapse to the ground. Walks Upon Earth is left with a cut from Sheriff Stone's grave, and Claire is left with a twisted ankle. Apologizing profusely, he helps Claire to walk to the jailhouse to get a first aid kit.
En route, Chad calls out to Evie, another re-enactor, but she's strangely spooked and runs away into an invisible barrier. Startled, she then scurries off in another direction, perplexing Chad. At the jailhouse, he and Claire suggest that Rosalie and Walks Upon Earth take their places for the rest of the re-enactment, and they even put original garb onto Walks Upon Earth. However, this induces some kind of seizure in him, and he demands that they all go to the hospital as soon as it's removed. Agreeing, Chad and Rosalie go to get their phones from the church.
There, they find all of the phones suspiciously destroyed. Worse, in the nave of the church they discover the hung corpse of the preacher re-enactor. Panicking, they try to leave, only to come face-to-face with Sheriff Stone, so they flee through another exit. Arriving back at the jailhouse, they collect Walks Upon Earth and Claire, with Chad half-carrying her to a hiding spot. They amend to flee the town, so Chad gives Walks Upon Earth a tomahawk for self-defense. However, he is possessed by the artifact and attacks them, prompting them all to flee. Chad and Claire nearly make it out, but slam into a barrier just like Evie. Eventually, Walks Upon Earth breaks free of the possession and tells them to ditch all the original artifacts which are spelled to the town and cannot leave. Doing so, both Chad and Claire are able to pass out of the town, and Chad helps Claire to safety.